Free Erotic Stories

Pay not attention to that third toothbrush!

In the mid 90’s, my wife and I were transitioning from apartment life to buying a home. Like many horny men, I had the urge to bring another woman into our sex life. I decided to buy a VHS tape that was a collection of MFF threesomes. As I recall, it was called “Colossal Combos”, or something like that. Pretty sure it’s still in a box somewhere in our basement, but we haven’t had a working VHS player in years. Some of the footage had bad lighting, and of course it made the porn actors look bad as well. I played it for my wife and watched for her reactions. I guess I was paying more attention to her reaction to the bad scenes than to the good ones. I was expecting her to say that she wasn’t interested, but to my surprise she admitted to being turned on by many of the better scenes. She also admitted to me that she was curious to explore another woman’s boobs. That’s all I had to hear!! This was the days of AOL and chat rooms, and I would spend hours in the local chat room seeking out potential women. I’m a pretty decent flirt, so I didn’t have much problem getting women to flirt back in talk just as dirty as my own. I found a good balance, learning not to talk about sex too quickly, but also not spending too much time talking to a girl that was never going to want to meet in person.

It wasn’t too many months before I met a woman, who I’ll call Lacey, that was interested in meeting a young couple. She didn’t mention this at first, but I soon found out that she was married and her husband was a moody guy that would occasionally tune her out for days at a time. Her and her husband, had done some swinging a few years before, so she knew she enjoyed both men and women. From our chats I discovered that Lacey is a few years older than me (and I’m 5 yrs older than my wife). Both Lacey and my wife are 5’1”, thin, and Italian. The biggest difference between the girls is that Lacey had D cups compared to my wife’s C cups. I met Lacey for lunch and was pleasantly surprised that she was easily as attractive (and sexy) in person as she was in her photos. I invited Lacey to our home that following weekend for coffee with both of us. While everyone was nervous, the girls seemed to get along great. When Lacey left after visiting for over an hour, I asked my wife what she thought of her. She said “she was very nice, but I don’t think I want to have sex with her”. I was disappointed, because I definitely wanted to have sex with Lacey, probably because of those luscious D cups I mentioned earlier! I asked my wife a few days later if we could invite her over again. To my surprise, she said yes. I’m guessing my wife wanted to play with those tits more than she had admitted to me when I asked previously. Like before, we invited Lacey to our home with the understanding that we’d like to try moving beyond just coffee. About 10 minutes in, Lacey took my wife’s hand and guided her to the floor in front of me. Lacey started to kiss my wife in a very sensual way. I was watching something I had previously only seen on videos! I remember encouraging my wife to touch her exposed cleavage. Lacey told me to relax and let her go at her own pace. Hated hearing that, but she was right. I don’t recall exactly how far that first date went beyond both girls ended up naked from the waist up, but I do remember that by the second date we were all naked together in our bed. By the third date, I was fucking Lacey, and even allowed to cum inside of her.

For my birthday, Lacey came over for a “birthday threesome” where the girls concentrated on my pleasure first. That was also the first time I ever had two women sucking on my cock at the same time! If you’ve never tried that, I HIGHLY recommend it! They would also take turns between riding my face and cock. I also remember the girls positioning themselves so I could alternate my cock back and forth between their pussies. Lacey was our regular girlfriend for a few years. Her and I would flirt for hours on AOL a few times a week. For my birthday the second year, the girls made up a story that Lacey would be out of town and wouldn’t be able to give me my “birthday threesome”. I was disappointed, but I knew she’d make it up to me on another night. The night of my birthday I came home, and saw balloons and a sign at the bottom of the stairs that suggested I should follow the ribbon that led upstairs. As I’m walking upstairs, it was obvious to me that I was going to get my special birthday after all. I got the our bedroom door and I saw another sign that said “The Party Is Here”. I opened the door and my two girls were on our bed making out wearing identical white lingerie. Damn that was hot!! I start to get undressed when Lacey tells me that the pizza will be here any minute, so I should probably stay dressed so I can go pay for it! Are you kidding me!!! But OK, I could wait another few minutes! That night was a lot like my previous birthday, and I recall she spent the night with us. Her husband traveled for work a lot, and this was before the days of iPhones and Apple Watches that gave away your location. So every once in awhile she’d spend the night in between us. Can you guess where my hand was all night?

One night she came over and gave me the best blowjob she had ever given me. She wasn’t a deepthroater, but boy she could generate strong suction. It was one of those orgasms that you swear you’re going to blow the woman’s head off when you explode into her mouth. A few minutes later she gave me some news that she had already shared with my wife. She was seeing a therapist to try to work on her marriage. The first thing the therapist told her was that she would have to stop the threesome. We stayed friends with Lacey, but mostly online as I don’t think she wanted to be tempted. She let us know that things were better with her husband, which was great. Apparently they were having sex one night and her husband mentioned that he’d like to try swinging again sometime. A light bulb must have appeared over Lacey’s head because replied “well, there’s a woman that I met on AOL in a cooking chat room that seems curious”. Lacey’s story was a lie, but believable and her husband didn’t question any details at all, he was just excited that his query was being answered almost as fast as he made it.

We met Lacey and her husband for drinks, and we all hit it off well. Of course a part of me was disappointed that I wouldn’t have my mini-harem anymore. A few weeks later we invited them to our home. As we gave them a tour, Lacey had to pretend it was her first time there, which was comical. I remember when we got to the master bathroom, they both peeked their heads in. I looked at the sink and noticed there were three toothbrushes there. We had never bothered to remove Lacey’s toothbrush after the threesome ended. Of course her husband didn’t suspect a thing, but I couldn’t help but laughing internally.

They became our “exclusive” couple for a few years until Lacey realized that her husband wasn’t going to change. He was basically a good guy, and I liked him a lot, but you can’t get mad at your wife and check into a hotel for the weekend without telling her where you are. My wife and I have had fights, but we’ve never gone to bed angry once in all our years of marriage. About a year after the divorce, we did have one more “fling” with Lacey, but I think she had outgrown the idea of a threesome, so it didn’t last long.

We went on to play with a few other single women and a few couples. By this time AOL was dead, so I found it much harder to find single women anymore. Hell, during the AOL days, I convinced one woman to play with us that didn’t even realize she was curious until I made it sound so fun….or at least that’s what she claimed. And we had started to raise a family, so we pretty much put swinging on the back burner. But the kids are finishing up college now, so watch out!

---