Free Erotic Stories

Tame but true!!!!

This story is about the first time (late 90s) that we played with another guy and/or added a third to our playtime. I used to love to have Beth dress in short skirts/dresses and do bend overs to let other men see her very pretty and clean shaven pussy (small pretty lips, very pink and yummy looking flower!) It really turns me on to let other men see her pretty pussy and little winking asshole when she bends over. She had (still does) an amazing ass and it looked so good bent over, shaking it for all to see! We would almost always go to the West side of town (lessened the chance of seeing someone we knew.)

This particular occasion was not the first time that we had done this, but the first time that we met someone we played with afterwards. Showing at the bookstores on Brookpark road was always hit and miss. It was mostly gay guys trolling, but occasionally a straight guy or couple looking for action. All of the bookstores had peep booths back then where you could watch movies in privacy and jack off…. city of Cleveland shut that stuff down more than 20 years ago.

Beth was shaking her pretty ass and doing bend overs in the store for several men. God it made me so hard watching her work her magic. Her ass and pussy were on full display for all to see, it was truly a beautiful sight! Her pussy was so wet and glistening and begging to be licked, sucked, and fucked!!! It looked like most/all the guys were gay, just one couple and our outing would be a dismal failure that day and we decided to leave. We went outside to the car and I lit up a smoke with Beth sitting in the passenger’s seat (Chevy Blazer… first SUV…LOL) with the door open. Sometimes we had some luck after we went outside. A couple (ginger dude and cute blond woman, couple we saw inside) pulled up alongside of us (hardly noticed them inside the store, they obviously noticed us and followed us out) and before we could even say “Hi” they got spooked by another car pulling up. (total shame, as they seemed like it would be a first time/cool match for us!)

I closed the passenger door and went around to the driver’s side and got in. Dude that spooked the couple/pulled up was in a BMW and a suit (again, hardly saw him inside the store.) He motioned for Beth to get out and she told me “I’m going to show him my ass!” She opened her door, got out pulled her skirt up and bent over to show him her ass and pussy. I got out and went over to her side of the car to make sure that everything was OK. She showed him all she had (pussy and ass and pulled her top down to show him her tits when he asked!) and he pulled out his cock and began stroking it! It was too weird doing this in broad daylight/we got scared and we got his number.

We called him and set up a time to meet/ our first meeting with another person to play, Beth said it seemed “more natural” to play with another man than a couple. We met at a very nice hotel/motel on Engle road. We brought all manner of booze (to get Beth in the mood and me too) and finger food! We met and the play began. Beth thought that a blow job would be a good ice breaker and give her a chance to inspect his cock, clean and not either too big or too thick… just a normal cock that was smaller and thinner than me. Well, after a few licks and sucks he erupted!

A couple of thick hot ropes of cum that was pretty much milky/to clear. Had to wait several minutes for recovery before he became hard again (understandable…. strange hot woman…. strange circumstances) Beth helped with hands and mouth to help him get hard again. He then began to lick every inch of Beth’s body. He started at her toes and worked his way up. His tongue found the crack of her ass and stayed there for quite a while. He licked and tongue fucked her ass for several minutes, humming his approval the entire time. He spent more time licking her ass than anything else (believe me, she had me do the same thing in the future, he started the adventure of anal play for her at that time… another story for another time!) He ate her pussy to orgasm and she loved it. I handed him a rubber and he went to town. After he came, he told me…”your up”… we did that several times… switching off….him cumming… then me… then him… etc.

We double teamed her for over an hour in every imaginable position. Beth came several times… don’t know how many, but the sheet was soaked under her pussy! He wasn’t the biggest (not by a long shot) nor the most skilled guy, but the new experience made up for it!

Not too much more to say, except that around 20 years later (last year 2018) he decided to call us (he kept our number that long, remember the 90s… cell phones not that prevalent)to see if we were still interested in a third wheel. Told him no, we didn’t do that anymore (could only imagine as he was 10-15 years older than us at the time…. Making him 65-70 and he wasn’t able to get it that hard 20 years ago.) So that is the story…. Tame… hope you enjoyed!!!