Free Erotic Stories

The One Who Got Away

Sometimes you feel like such a fool. Then you get fooled for the second time and just have to laugh. We made arrangements with a guy who will remain anonymous due to my good nature. We were to meet him at a local bar close to our home on a Saturday night at 7pm. He was so excited about meeting us...or so he said. I had talked to him on the phone, he was privy to a few of our g rated pictures and he shared a few of him with us. He was a good looking guy, looked normal (whatever normal is) and had all the right answers. He said he was from Virgina and that he would drive all the way up to Pa because of how beautiful my wife is. He said he would book a room, pay for it and show us a great time. Well, we sat in the bar until 7:15 and no Booger. I decided to call him and see if he was getting close. No answer on his phone. I called about 10 minutes later and still no answer. I left him a message telling him I hoped he was not playing games with us. We waited until 8 pm and then called it quits, feeling like we had be HAD! We spent the rest of the night out with some platonic friends we know well from our town. Then we went home in spite of old Booger and torn up the sheets ourselves.

Now comes the best part. Old Booger wrote us a e-mail sent to our gmail account (I had previously blocked him from contacting us at the swinger site) telling us this great story how he had to stop at his mothers house on the way to Pa. and help her light her furnace. He had sat down on the couch to talk to her and that is when he must have dropped his phone. Which he told us is why we could not get a hold of him. He said he actually arrived at the Pub where we were to meet at about 8:05. Funny...we must have just missed him. So he tells us he will come up again and buy us dinner, and drinks and pay for the room if we will just give him another chance. So now I bet you are all thinking either I am fool or he set us up again....WRONG! He shows this time! Nice looking guy, great personality...we played some pool had some drinks, laughed at each other and I thought this is it..we are going to have a great time. My wife seemed to like him and she was acting very horny. So we head to the hotel and he goes and books the room. Meets us in the parking lot out back and we all head to the room. We fire up the heat and I start to kiss my wife and slip the low scoop neck top she has on off of her to expose her beautiful breasts. Booger is very excited, while I am kissing her he reaches around from behind her to cup her breasts while he is kissing her shoulder...she starts to moan. I slowly reach down and undo her jeans and push them down as I lower her to the bed. She is pulling at my jeans so I help by slipping them off as I pull hers off. Next come her panties, by this time Booger is starting to sweat. I can see the beads on his face. I then pull her panties off to expose her beautiful bald pussy (she had laser removal, very nice guys!) I start to lick her pussy as Booger starts to lick her breasts. She is already very wet and moaning out loud. Booger asks me if he can change places with me, I oblige by moving up to kiss my wife on the lips as he slips down between her legs to kiss her pussy. He is working like crazy down there, putting a finger in her as he is licking her. She is moaning very loud by now and I move up to her and she takes me in her mouth. I am in heaven, she is heaven and he is moaning as loudly as my wife. She is so hot by now she tells Booger she wants to feel his cock in her pussy. He springs up and moves up between her legs. He starts to move to put his cock in her and remembers I had asked him to use protection. I head to the table and retrieve a condom for him. He takes the condom and for some reason heads to the bathroom. While he is gone I cannot help myself, my wife is laying naked on the bed her sweet pussy lips glistening I move between her legs and slowly ease my cock into her. She is extremely hot now...moaning and pumping back at me already on fire. Booger emerges from the bathroom pulling his pants on saying he left his keys on the check in desk and that he would run down and get them. He also said he would leave his shoes in the room... I said ok. Then again as he is getting dressed he repeats.."I'll leave my shoes in the room..??? Now it hits me...what a strange thing...why does he keep telling me he'll leave his shoes in the room. So he leaves and I continue to make love to my wife. We are having a great time and then it hits me...He's been gone for 30 minutes. So me and my wife setup our video camera and start to make love again filming ourselves forgetting that Booger still has not come back. We play for about another 45 minutes and we both cum together and she rolls off of me and we make a drink. Both of us wonder out loud..."Do you think he left without his shoes!" I start to laugh uncontrollably. Could this be possible? He left without his shoes? Why did he leave without his shoes? Why did he leave at all? My wife is bummed, even though she see's the humor in him leaving without his shoes...she was looking forward to a very hot night. She cannot help but laugh with me...I mean my sides are hurting from thinking of Booger riding down the road with no shoes...We finish our drink, pack up the cooler and I grab his shoes! They are my size after all. So listen guys, if ever we meet and you freak and run out without your shoes...consider them mine. Now I have to put on Boogers shoe's and go rotate my tires.

---